Month: October 2017

149. Adelphoe (The Brothers) by Terence (160 BC)

Plot:  Two brothers, Aeschinus and Ctesipho, are split to be raised separately, but remain good friends. Ctesipho is raised by his poor hardworking father Demea on their farm, while Aeschinus is fostered to his rich uncle Micio in the city. The two fathers have very different philosophies of fatherhood : Micio allows Aeschinus a free hand in all his adventures,  and pays the bills for his excesses to win his love; while Demea tries to force  sobriety and responsibility onto Ctesipho.

Then one night, Aeschinus breaks into a slave-owner’s house to abduct a girl, and bring her back to his house. Next door, another girl he seduced and has promised marriage is about to give birth to their child. Has Micio’s laxity raised a wild and uncontrollable boy, or is there more to Aeschinus’  actions than first appears?

The last play in the Penguin edition of Terence’s Comedies (014044324X)

My thoughts:  A more mature story than his earlier plays, but still lifted from an earlier Greek play, The Brothers is really more about the two older brothers Demea and Micio, and the manner with which they view their role as fathers.

A shorter play than the others makes for more sudden entrances and exits by the players, giving it the feel of a more modern comedy. The conniving slave is not the centre of attention, and although Demea may seem miserly and authoritarian to many of the characters, his apparent Scrooge-like transformation towards the end contains a humorous and gentle sting for his easygoing brother Micio.

Favourite lines/passages:

Demea’s final speech hits the right note:

Demea: “I wanted to show you, Micio, that what our boys thought was your good nature and charm didn’t come from a way of living which was sincere or from anything right or good, but from your weakness, indulgence and extravagance. Now Aeschinus, if you and your brother dislike  my ways because I won’t humour you in all your wishes, right or wrong, I wash my hands of you – you can spend and squander and do whatever you like. On the other hand, being young, you are short-sighted, over-eager and heedless, and you may like a word of advice or reproof from me on occasion, as well as my support at the proper time, well I’m here at your service.” page 386.

But I also can’t begrudge Micio’s sheer love for his adopted son either

Micio : “My son, I have heard the whole story; I understand for I love you, so all you do touches my heart.”   page 371

Personal rating:  7/10

Also in that year: Judas Maccabeus, leader of the Jewish revolt, dies fighting the Seleucids.

The reads in between:  Hercule Poirot digs for the truth in the archaeological Murder in Mesopotamia. Christie often accompanied her husband on his digs so had some local colour to add to this murder mystery. I correctly suspected the secondary villain and guessed the murderer, but more by choosing the most unlikely suspect that true deduction.

Also read Brandon Sanderson’s The Final Empire (#1 in the Mistborn series) – deserves the high praise it gets on Goodreads  – sort of a cross between Lord of the Rings, Mission Impossible and Spiderman – that should peak your curiosity. Not only is it the first in a series but each of Sanderson’s series are loosely connected in a much bigger universe and he plans to have 30-40 books across the worlds, beside his work on finishing Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time series. A busy lad!

Next : How Rome became great : Polybius’ Histories, or, The Rise of the Roman Empire

 

Advertisements
There must be a word for it ….

There must be a word for it ….

My work week is split fairly evenly between a bookshop and a public library. At the former, I see new books arrive all the time and which books people are buying or waiting for, and which authors have new titles about to be published. At the latter I see what people borrow or request, and what is on the shelves from the last ten to fifteen years as I shelve the  returns. At least half the titles are fiction. I am surrounded day and night by literally thousands of books! And of course, it’s not just the books on the open shelves – I can browse the library stacks of low use titles, I can access the childrens’ and teen collections without feeling like an intruder, I can even score an occasional damaged book from the bookshop or an uncorrected proof copy of a new release. And unlike the university library I used to work in, I can imagine wanting to read a goodly percentage of the books about me now.

When I was young, reading was my consuming hobby, being neither sporty or adventurous. At university studying sciences, my reading for pleasure waned. While never completely stopped, it is only in the past few years that my reading has returned to those high levels of childhood.

Surrounded by books all day, I now feel overwhelmed by the sheer number of books I haven’t read. I will never get to read them all. This dismay is part of the reason for this enormous quest and blog.

“So many books, so little time”. Is there a word for this?

148. Phormio by Terence (161 BC)

148. Phormio by Terence (161 BC)

Plot:  Young Antipho marries Phanium while his father Demipho is abroad. She is penniless with no dowry, which enrages Demipho on his return. Meanwhile Antipho’s cousin Phaedria has fallen in love with Pamphila, a slave girl about to be sold off, but he has no money to rescue and marry her. His father, Chremes (Demipho’s brother) is also abroad on one of his frequent visits to his secret second wife and his daughter but they have disappeared. Phormio , a clever rascal and  friend to Antipho and Phaedria, promises to help them both.

My thoughts:  More enjoyable than the earlier plays, especially as there was no overt violence to women, but it didn’t quite have the sparkle of The Eunuch. The plot is twisty but doesn’t lose the audience (that is, me).

I mentioned in the last post that the stage setup remains quite basic and consistent, with just the two neighbouring houses. I should also mention that, while the courtesans and older women (wives, slaves and nurses) appear on stage, the beautiful young women (in this case, Phanium and Pamphila) never appear but are spoken to as if they are in the houses. I presume that if only male actors were allowed to perform on stage, they could not provide a sufficient illusion of feminine beauty necessary to make the desperation of the male characters believable and lift the comedy above farce.

As mentioned in earlier posts, Terence borrowed content from Greek plays, which was almost standard practice for Latin playwrights at this time, and subsequently both this play and Terence’s next (The Brothers) were used by Moliere as the basis of two of his plays. As Terence said in his prologue to The Eunuch: “Nothing is ever said which has not been said before”

Personal rating:  6/10

Also about this time: Public libraries appear in Rome. Yay!

Next : The final play by Terence, Adelphoe (The Brothers)

 

147. Eunuchus (The Eunuch) by Terence (161 BC)

147. Eunuchus (The Eunuch) by Terence (161 BC)

Plot:  Chaerea has fallen in love at first sight with the young maiden Pamphila, and disguises himself as a eunuch so he can gain access to her bedroom where he ‘seduces’ her. His older brother Phaedria is in love with the courtesan Thais, but has a rival in the soldier Thraso. The latter has made a present of Pamphila to Thais (who is trying to restore her to her family), but only if Thais will make Thraso her number one suitor.

My thoughts: Paradoxically I enjoyed this play far more than Terence’s other plays, in spite of the fact that at the centre of this ‘comedy’ there is still a young woman sexually assaulted.

The storyline was better structured, and the intentions of all the characters were easy to follow. It also featured the whole host of stock characters – the bragging soldier, his toady companion milking him for meals, the artful courtesan, the obsessed young men and the dottery old father, with much more opportunity for actual comedy – the young man dressing as a eunuch, the braggart and his sycophantic ‘yes-man’.  I can almost be persuaded that everyone has a happy ending, even the young girl, reunited with her family and offered marriage by her love-struck assailant.

I guess I just have to take on board this treatment of women, particularly slaves, was an everyday occurrence, rating only a small amount of sympathy from a Roman audience, and justified due to  the uncontrollable desires of young men ‘boys will be boys’ mentality.

The stage presentation is remarkably static in all the Roman plays so far. Two houses side by side, with the city centre off to the audience’s right, and the countryside off to the left. Terence also uses the same range of characters mentioned above, and even recycles the names of characters across his plays (although they do not represent the same people from play to play)

Personal rating:  A surprising and somewhat guilty 7/10. If you read one Terence play, this is probably the one.

Next :  Staying with Terence, his fifth play, Phormio.

 

146. Heauton Timorumenos (The Self-Tormentor) by Terence (163 BC)

Plot:  Menedemus is working himself relentlessly night and day in his fields as private atonement for driving his only son Clinia away rather than condone his son’s love interest, the young maid Antiphila.  His neighbour Chremes tries to cheer him up, unaware that his own son Clitipho is infatuated with the courtesan Bacchis, who now arrives along with Antiphila at Chremes’ house,   where Clinia is hiding. The family slave Syrus tries to swindle the money Clitipho needs to keep Bacchis satisfied, and convinces Clinia to pretend he loves Bacchis. Meanwhile Chremes persuades Menedemus to hide the regret and affection he feels overwhelmingly for Clinia when he does return.

All clear so far…? No??

My thoughts:  A difficult play to follow – I kept losing track of what Memedemus and Chremes were supposed to believe, who was supposed to be in love with who, and where Syrus was going to get the money from. I read the middle third of the play twice and it only just helped.

Halfway through, It is revealed that Antiphila is actually the daughter of Chremes, who he had ordered to be abandoned to die in the wilderness as a baby years ago because she was a girl. His anger with his wife for not obeying him, and thereby risking the ignominy of having his daughter become a slave or a courtesan rather than starve to death as an infant, sours the whole story and took any hint of comedy away completely for  me.  Terence seems to gloss over the atrocities and sorrows inflicted on the women in his stories, using them simply as so much background to his plot entanglements.

 

Personal rating: 3/10

Also around this time:   From 167 to 160 BC, Maccabean Jews were rebelling against the Seleucid Empire and Greek influence. Their victory at the Battle of Beth Zur in 164 BC led to the recapture of Jerusalem.

My reads in between:

  • Tales of St. Austins, a very early Wodehouse in his School stories era, with short stories featuring the students and teachers of said school, mostly revolving around the next rugby or cricket match, and not getting caught outside school bounds. For Wodehouse addicts only.
  • Playing with Fire, the second in the Skulduggery Pleasant series. Not as good as the first but only because the joy of meeting the characters has already been had. Still a great read.

Next :  The Eunuch by Terence

 

Listophilia

It’s a slow day in the bookshop. It’s raining (finally) and customers are also blowing into the shop in sudden gusts and out again. So I have time to think in between.

As I warned in my very first post, I do love lists, and naturally lists of books are of interest. I am toying with the idea of tagging my book posts with icons when the title appears on a ‘best of … ‘ list, so how would that have gone so far?

    ‘1001 Books to read before you die‘ lists titles chronologically (yay!) and varies across editions. The only Ancient Greek to feature in any edition is Aseop’s Fables (no Homer?!).

And then there’s ‘1001 Childrens’ Books to Read before You Grow Up’  as well 😊

 

‘Great Books of the Western World’ is also chronologically ordered, and covers 60 volumes in its second edition. Far more in tune with my efforts so far, it starts with the complete works of Homer, Aeschylus, Sophocles, Euripides, Aristophanes, Herodotus, Thucydides, Plato, Aristotle, the medical texts of Hippocrates and Galen, and the mathematical treatises of Euclid and Archimedes, Apollonius and Nicomachus (I came off the rails with Plato and Aristotle, and didn’t even attempt the mathematics!) However, GBWW is a little more picky with the Romans, omitting Plautus and Terence, Cicero, Caesar, Horace and Ovid – but then they have an imposed publishing-driven limit.

Susan Wise Bauer’s ‘The Well-Educated Mind’ lists roughly 30 titles in each of six categories : Fiction, Drama, Poetry, Autobiography, History and Politics, and Science. So far I have unknowingly started her Drama, History and Science lists, doing pretty well with Herodotus and Thucydides, Plato’s Republic, Aeschylus’ Agamemnon, Sophocles’ Oedipus the King, Euripides’ Medea, Aristophanes’  The Birds, and Aristotle’s Poetics, Hippocrates,  Gilgamesh and of course Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey,  but skipped Aristotle’s Physics. 😦

 

 Of course my most successful list is actually Penguin’s Catalogue of Classics, and it also stretches just far enough outside the Western Canon for my purposes, covering Chinese, Japanese, and South Asian classics.

 

Have I forgotten something obvious??

145. Hecyra (The Mother-in-Law) by Terence (c.165 BC)

145. Hecyra (The Mother-in-Law) by Terence (c.165 BC)

Plot: Young Pamphilus is convinced to break off his affair with the courtesan Bacchis and marry Philumena. But seven months later, Philumena runs back to her parents’ house, and it is generally believed that it must have been some quarrel or  insult from Pamphilus’ mother Sostra that caused her to flee. In reality Philumena is trying to hide a pregnancy resulting from her being raped by an unknown man two months before the arranged wedding.

My copies of the comedies of Terence are all taken from the Penguin Classic The Comedies, translated by Betty Radice (ISBN 014044324X)

My thoughts:   And here was I thinking that the dating of Terence’s plays was straightforward and past dispute. While The Girl from Andros (166 BC) is agreed to be the first, the fate of what I will treat as the second (The Mother-in-Law) is a little chequered. Originally staged in 165 BC, the play was interrupted by a surge of people responding to a rumour that a tight-rope walker was appearing. In its second outing in 160 BC, again a mob interrupted proceedings expecting a gladiatorial battle. Finally in its third outing, again in 160 BC, the cast got through to the end and the play was a success. In the meantime, three of Terence’s other plays had been performed. Anyway as Lucius Ambivius Turpio, lead actor and producer of this third attempt would have undoubtedly said, let’s get on with the show.

By now, prologues are no longer used to set the scene of the play but to beg the audience’s indulgence, or to respond to the attack of critics. Dialogue between two characters in the opening scene is used to explain the background to the situation where the story begins, in this case that Pamphilus has married Philumena and stopped his attentions to the courtesan Bacchis, and that Philumena has gone back to her parents without explanation.

The play itself is  more like a soap opera than the comedies that Plautus wrote, but with the same misunderstandings and coincidences abounding. The women are all treated badly because of the misunderstandings, yet each behaves nobly; even and perhaps especially the courtesan Bacchis who agrees to visit Philumena’s family home and swear that she has not seen Pamphilus since his marriage.

The mother-in law in question is Pamphilus’ mother Sostrata, who is ill used by all. Suspected of having driven Philumena away, and used as an excuse by Pamphilus to abandon his wife, she is also accused by her own husband of causing the problem;  just as Philumena’s father Phidippus blames his wife Myrrina for using the pregnancy to try and break up the young couple. Worst of all, poor Philumena has been raped, forced into marriage with a man known to be obsessed with a prostitute, and now has to somehow hide her pregnancy from her husband and his family.

As I try to never tell readers the entire plot, I will leave off with the obvious spoiler that there is a happy ending so it ranks as a mild domestic comedy, but it has all the potential of a tragedy.

Personal rating: 5/10

Next : Terence’s ‘third’ play,  Heauton Timorumenos  (The Self-Tormentor) (c.163 BC)

PS The excellent pic attached to this post comes from Monica Dorkface at DeviantArt